Viewers found "Wrong Aisle" engaging, particularly highlighting the dramatic twists and turns of the plot. Many focused on the character of Edafe, the cheating fiancé, with some calling him "wicked and evil" and others praising the actor's portrayal of the heartbreaker. The film's exploration of infidelity and its consequences resonated with some audience members, while others critiqued specific scenes, such as the bedroom scene, for being unrealistic. Overall, the film sparked discussion about relationships, trust, and the importance of recognizing red flags.