Overall, audiences reacted positively to "Loving Olivia Wellington," praising the acting and storyline. Many viewers highlighted the performance of MC Lively as Nnamdi’s supportive friend, with some stating that "having a good friend is better than having siblings who doesn't care." Blossom Chukwujekwu's portrayal was also lauded, as was Ego Nwosu's natural and believable performance. Some viewers criticised a scene where a character left his partner in a dangerous situation, and others felt the film's view count did not reflect its quality.