Viewers overwhelmingly celebrated "Her Fifth Sense," particularly praising Pearl Watts's performance as a blind woman, with some calling it the best portrayal of blindness they had seen in a Nigerian film. Many lauded the film's romantic elements and the chemistry between Watts and Maurice Sam. The ending, which did not restore the character's sight, was appreciated for its realism and message of love beyond physical limitations. A few viewers mentioned minor plot issues, but the overall sentiment was one of deep appreciation.