Audiences responded strongly to "Love Me Again," engaging with its themes of forgiveness and marital struggles. Many viewers debated Favour's actions and the realism of Jason's ultimate decision, with some appreciating his capacity for forgiveness and others arguing that his acceptance of her was unrealistic or even condoned abuse. Several commenters praised Nkem's role as a supportive friend, while others complimented Detola Jones' resemblance to Genevieve Nnaji. A small number of viewers expressed concern that the film normalized toxic relationship dynamics.