Overall, audiences responded positively to "A Stitch In Crime," particularly praising the performances of Liz Selle and Diana Luvanda. Many viewers celebrated Selle's portrayal of the "wicked auntie," noting her eloquence and captivating screen presence. Luvanda also received considerable support, with some highlighting her representation of Kenyan talent. While most found the storyline engaging, a few critics suggested that the plot was too simplistic and the acting was of low quality.