Overall, audiences reacted positively to *Hearts That Stay*, with particular enthusiasm for actress Imisioluwa. Many viewers stated they watched the film specifically because of her involvement, praising her performance and expressing pride in her success. Some appreciated Eddie Watson's approach to filmmaking, noting the care taken in the production. A segment of viewers also highlighted the performances of other cast members, such as Kamo and Richie, and engaged with the film's themes of loyalty and love, with one noting, "it's a beautiful movie."