Viewers responded positively to "Restaurant Girl," highlighting its romantic storyline and themes of overcoming trauma. Many enjoyed the chemistry between the lead characters, particularly during their initial phone conversations, with one describing it as "fire oo." Some appreciated the film's message about sincere rejection, while others found the plot implausible, specifically the circumstances of the characters' first meeting. Technical aspects, such as the soundtrack and perceived continuity errors in a supporting character's hair, also drew notice.