"Campus Queen 2" has been well received by viewers, who particularly enjoyed the romantic storyline and the chemistry between Annabel and Eronini. Many expressed satisfaction with the film's ending, favoring Darius as Annabel's romantic partner. Anderson's character was widely disliked, with one viewer saying he was so annoying they "could punch you through the screen." Some found Annabel's makeup to be excessive, but overall, the acting was praised as natural and the plot was lauded for its ability to tell a touching story without relying on kissing scenes.