Overall, audiences reacted positively to "A Flicker of Us", praising the acting, particularly that of Bambam, and the emotional storyline. Many appreciated the film's themes of forgiveness and the complexities of friendship, while others debated the characters' motivations, especially those of Lala and Tiwa. Some viewers lauded the soundtrack and the film's production quality, deeming it "cinema standard." A few noted minor plot inconsistencies, but these did not detract significantly from their overall enjoyment.