Overall, audiences responded positively to "Her Sister's Choice," praising the performances of Chioma Chukwuka and Stephen Odimgbe, with some highlighting Chukwuka's dramatic flair. Viewers appreciated the film's exploration of themes like love, sacrifice, and the dangers of being overprotective. The narrative's focus on choices and consequences also resonated with many, while some found the dialogue memorable, noting the exchange, "you never still marry, you never still born."