Viewers responded positively to "When Feelings Cross", particularly praising the acting and the unexpected plot twists. John Ekanem's dual performance as twins garnered significant attention, with audiences impressed by his portrayal of both characters. Some appreciated the soundtrack and the mother's supportive role, while others found minor issues with accents or plot contrivances, such as the sisters not having met the groom before the wedding. Overall, audiences found the film engaging, with one commenter noting, "This is what we call a movie not predictable at all".