Viewers responded positively to "My Father's Wife," praising the performances of Chika Ike, Tony Umez, and Eddie Watson. Many appreciated the storyline's unexpected twists and turns, with some drawing parallels to a popular song about dating a former partner's father. Commenters also noted the film's emotional impact, with one saying the movie "made me cry it touched my heart." A few audience members speculated about the true nature of the characters' relationships, suggesting hidden motivations.