Viewers generally responded positively to "When Grace Meets Desire", praising the performances of Chioma Chukwuka Akpotha and John Ekanem. Many appreciated the film's exploration of faith, love, and societal expectations, particularly the supportive relationship between the pastor and her daughter. Some commenters highlighted the film's mature handling of a May-December romance and its message that "you can choose your happiness and still be in the will of God." A few viewers, however, expressed reservations about the portrayal of a pastor in a romantic relationship, citing concerns about biblical standards.