Viewers responded positively to "Father Samuel", particularly enjoying the comedic elements and the performances of the cast. Many appreciated the film's exploration of themes like parental expectations and personal desires, with some singling out specific characters for praise, such as Amanda's father. The comedic timing of Nosa Rex was a recurring highlight, with one viewer noting, "all the actors played their roles excellently". Some found the pacing quick, exemplified by Samuel's eagerness, while others expressed a desire for a sequel.