Viewers are deeply engaged with "Choice of Hearts," dissecting the complexities of long-term relationships, financial struggles, and the allure of "toxic masculinity." Michael Dappa's portrayal of a struggling man resonated strongly, with one commenter noting how "He stole my heart...it just reflects the struggle of every average Nigerian guy." Many discussed the female lead's emotional journey and the ethical dilemmas of being with a struggling partner, even debating if she emotionally cheated. Overall, audiences praised the relatability and thought-provoking themes of the movie, finding the performances authentic and the storyline compelling.