Overall, audiences responded positively to "What The Heart Carries", with many praising the storyline and production quality. Viewers particularly appreciated Felix's character, describing him as a model of love and gratitude, and lauded the film's exploration of themes like love, sacrifice, and the limitations of wealth. Some commenters, however, felt aspects of the plot were unrealistic, with one noting "that was not a boardroom conversation sha", and others critiqued the film's pacing and directing.