Reactions to "Love Elsewhere" are largely focused on the performances, plot, and themes of infidelity and karma. Bright Morgan and Chinonso received considerable praise, with fans declaring Morgan a "super star" and expressing excitement about his role. Young actress Anita was also lauded as "very talented and brilliant". The film sparked discussions about marital respect, the consequences of cheating, and the perceived "audacity" of the wife's actions, with some viewers stating "Comfort, you deserve what you are getting. Aura for aura".