Audience reactions to "Tears of Love" are largely positive, with many praising the performances, particularly those of Ray and Chinenye, for their emotional depth and realism. Several viewers highlighted Chinenye's ability to portray emotional scenes, with one commenting, "Nnenye can cry for Africa... she's just good." Liz Selle also received acclaim for a standout, versatile performance. The film's narrative, which explores themes of exploitation and resilience, resonated with viewers, prompting discussions about family trauma and the importance of not judging a book by its cover, with one viewer writing, "Watching for the 2nd time. Love this movie, it teaches not to judge a book by its cover."