Audience reactions to "Alice My Lover" appear heavily influenced by the presence of comedian Brain Jotter. Many viewers explicitly stated they watched the film because of him, with some humorously noting his character's attire and comedic timing. However, some viewers expressed disappointment when his screen time was less than anticipated, with one stating "there is no need to download" if he is not featured prominently. Some viewers also discussed plot points, particularly Alice's manipulation of the male characters and the film's blend of love, jealousy, and spiritual themes.