"Dreaming of You" seems to have resonated with audiences primarily for its romantic elements and themes of kindness and destiny. Many viewers praised the on-screen chemistry between Chika Ike and Chidi Dike, highlighting specific scenes like the dinner date and the initial awkward meeting between their characters. The film's exploration of character development, particularly Elena's, also drew positive attention, with one viewer touched by "that deep conversation" between her and Dax. Conversely, some found fault with the film's pacing, questioning the believability of certain plot points like a character's delayed reaction in a crucial scene.