Overall, audiences responded positively to "A Gigolo for Vals", particularly praising the chemistry between the lead actors, Taye Arimoro and Teniola Aladese, with many noting it felt natural and engaging. Arimoro's performance was lauded for its realism and professionalism, while Aladese was commended for her genuine portrayal. Some viewers, however, critiqued the styling and wardrobe choices for Arimoro, suggesting improvements were needed to complement his physique and presence; one viewer said, "Whoever is dressing Tayo needs to stop". The film's humor and relatable themes also resonated with many.