Overall, audiences reacted positively to "Heart Of Love," with particular praise directed towards the performances of several actors. Liz Selle, who played Nonso's mother, was singled out for her portrayal of a supportive and understanding parent, with some calling her "the best African Mother." Omeche and Ray's chemistry was also well-received. Some viewers criticized Nonso's character for his behaviour in the relationship and Cynthia for being "very controlling."